clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Reader Poll – Villanova’s Greatest Small Forward

Reader Poll – Villanova’s Greatest Small Forward

Jack Devine in 1954

This is the fourth in our series of reader polls to select Villanova's all-time greatest players, this one to select the greatest small forward. The full list of 35 nominees for all positions and the selection criteria used is provided at the end of this post. There is still time to vote in our prior polls by double-clicking on the following links:

SELECT TWO NAMES from the nominees, listed chronologically on the next page, that represent the two best small forwards in Villanova's history. In a subsequent poll the readers will determine Villanova’s all-time starting five from the ten finalists.

Paul Arizin… 6' 4" small forward … played from 1947-1950 … arguably the most storied of all Nova players … holds the Villanova record for most points in a game (85, albeit against Naval Air Material Center) … after being cut for two straight years from his high school team was discovered as a Villanova freshman by Coach Al Severance ... became a high-scoring forward for the Cats, scoring 1,648 points (#14 all-time) in 82 games (20.1 ppg) in only three varsity seasons … is credited with inventing the jump shot, developed out of necessity while playing at St. Monica’s in South Philly to avoid falling on the slippery floor … was named the collegiate player of the year in his senior year (1950) after leading the nation with 25.3 points per game … was drafted by the Philadelphia Warriors of the fledgling NBA in 1950 and went on to a 13-year career with that team … played in 10 NBA All-Star Games, was the 1952 NBA All-Star Game MVP and named to the All-NBA First-Team in 1952, 1956, and 1957 … retired with the then third highest career point total (16,266) in NBA history and was inducted into the Basketball Hall of Fame in 1978 … #11 jersey retired by Villanova in 1994 … inducted into the Big Five Hall of Fame in 2000 ... greatest honor, however, came in 1996 when he was named one of the 50 Greatest Players in NBA history.

Jack Devine … small forward who played from 1952-1955 … scored 1,263 points (#37 all-time) and 1,181 rebounds (#3 all-time) in only three varsity seasons … was the 35th player chosen in the 1955 NBA draft, selected by the Philadelphia Warriors.

Hank Siemiontkowski… 6’5 small forward …played from 1969- 1972 … scored 1,224 points (#39 all-time) over 90 games (13.6 ppg;) and 739 rebounds (#14 all-time) in only three varsity seasons … best remembered for his performance in the 1971 NCAA tournament, scoring a career-high 31 points in an overtime win over Western Kentucky University and 19 points in the Wildcats' loss to the UCLA in the 1971 NCAA final game … was named to the 1971 NCAA East Regional all-tournament team along with Howard Porter … was the 50th selection in the 1972 NBA draft by the Cleveland Cavaliers, playing only one season ... inducted into the Big Five Hall of Fame in 1988.

Keith Herron ... 6'6" small forward ... played from 1974-1978 ... upon graduation was Villanova's all-time leading scorer with 2,170 points (#3 all-time) over 117 games (18.5 ppg; #9 all-time ... named to Basketball Weekly's All-East team, The Sporting News All-America team, the All-NIT team, and twice to the All-Big Five team ... drafted by the Portland Trail Blazers in the second round of the 1978 NBA Draft ... played for the Atlanta Hawks in 1978–79, Detroit Pistons in 1980–81, and Cleveland Cavaliers in 1981–82, averaging 9.8 ppg and 2.0 rpg in 21.1 mpg ... inducted into the Big Five Hall of Fame in 1984 ... #33 jersey retired by Villanova .

Doug West… 6'7" small forward … played for the Cats from 1985-89 … scored 2,037 points (#5 all-time) over 138 games (14.8 ppg; #20 all time), 630 rebounds (#26 all-time), 257 assists (#25 all-time), and 127 steals (#19 all time) and 51 blocks (#18 all-time) … was an athletic, well-rounded player who could score as well as defend … in 1988 helped lead the Wildcats to the Elite Eight and was named to the all-Southeast Regional team … was later named to the Big Five Hall of Fame … selected by the Minnesota Timberwolves in the second round of the 1989 NBA Draft … traded to the Vancouver Grizzlies in 1997 …over a twelve-year NBA career tallied 6,477 points, 1,670 rebounds, and 1,292 assists … inducted into the Big Five Hall of Fame in 1996 ... was named an assistant coach for the Villanova Wildcats, replacing Ed Pinckney in 2007.

select up to 2
[poll id="38"]

Full List of Nominees:

To come up with the nominees, we considered players whose Villanova jerseys have been retired, were among the all-time Villanova statistical leaders, earned All-America recognition, had success in the NCAA tournament, or were selected in the NBA draft. Active Villanova players are not eligible. The NCAA has made significant rule changes over the years that make statistical comparisons of players across generations difficult. To read more on this topic, see our post “Scottie’s Stats Under Howard’s Rules.” Our nominees are:

Nominee Pos Last Year
Jim Washington F/C 1965
Howard Porter F/C 1971
John Pinone F/C 1983
Jason L. Lawson F/C 1997
Malik Allen F/C 2000
Michael Bradley F/C 2001
Alex Bradley F 1981
Ed Pinckney F 1985
Harold Pressley F 1986
Tim Thomas F 1997
Curtis Sumpter F 2007
Dante Cunningham F 2009
Paul Arizin SF 1950
Larry Hennessy SF 1953
Jack Devine SF 1955
Hank Siemiontkowski SF 1972
Keith Herron SF 1978
Doug West SF 1989
Hubie White SG 1962
Johnny Jones SG 1969
Chris Ford SG 1972
Kerry Kittles SG 1996
Gary Buchanan SG 2003
Allan Ray SG 2006
Randy Foye SG 2006
Bob Schafer PG 1955
Walter "Wali" Jones PG 1964
Bill Melchionni PG 1966
Tom Ingelsby PG 1973
Rory Sparrow PG 1980
Stuart Granger PG 1983
Kenny Wilson PG 1989
Alvin Williams PG 1997
Kyle Lowry PG 2006
Scottie Reynolds PG 2010