Inside Lacrosse has named their preseason All-Americans as a part of the annual Face-Off Yearbook. The First, Second, and Third teams each are comprised of 15 players, while the Honorable Mention team consists of 47. Villanova junior midfielder Thomas Croonquist (North Caldwell, NJ/Seton Hall Prep) was named to the Honorable Mention team and is the only Wildcat representative among all of the preseason All-Americans. Croonquist, who specializes in face-offs, has won 60% over face-offs over his career, which ranks third all-time in Villanova history. He also scooped up 104 ground balls, and notched 4 assists to go along with 3 caused turnovers during his time on the Main Line. The full list of preseason All-Americans is below.
FIRST TEAM
| A | Rob Pannell | Sr. | Cornell |
| A | Peter Baum | Sr. | Colgate |
| A | Marcus Holman | Sr. | North Carolina |
| A | Will Manny | Sr. | UMass |
| M | Thomas Schreiber | Jr. | Princeton |
| M | Jeremy Noble | Jr. | Denver |
| M | Chris LaPierre | Sr. | Virginia |
| M | Josh Hawkins | Sr. | Loyola |
| FO | Chase Carraro | Sr. | Denver |
| LSM | Jesse Bernhardt | Sr. | Maryland |
| D | Tucker Durkin | Sr. | Johns Hopkins |
| D | Joe Fletcher | Jr. | Loyola |
| D | Brian Megill | Sr. | Syracuse |
| D | Jason Noble | Sr. | Cornell |
| G | John Kemp | Sr. | Notre Dame |
SECOND TEAM
| A | Mike Sawyer | Sr. | Loyola |
| A | Jordan Wolf | Jr. | Duke |
| A | Logan Schuss | Sr. | Ohio State |
| A | Garrett Thul | Sr. | Army |
| M | Rob Guida | Jr. | Johns Hopkins |
| M | Jimmy Marlatt | Jr. | Notre Dame |
| M | John Haus | Sr. | Maryland |
| M | Adrian Sorichetti | Sr. | Hofstra |
| FO | RG Keenan | Jr. | North Carolina |
| LSM | Scott Ratliff | Sr. | Loyola |
| D | Henry Lobb | Jr. | Duke |
| D | Goran Murray | So. | Maryland |
| D | Ty Souders | Jr. | Lehigh |
| D | Jake Smith | Sr. | UMass |
| G | Austin Kaut | Jr. | Penn State |
THIRD TEAM
| A | Zach Palmer | Sr. | Johns Hopkins |
| A | David DiMaria | Sr. | Lehigh |
| A | Matt Donovan | So. | Cornell |
| A | Ryan Walsh | So. | Colgate |
| M | Rob Emery | Jr. | Virginia |
| M | John Ranagan | Sr. | Johns Hopkins |
| M | John Glesener | So. | Army |
| M | Davis Butts | Sr. | Loyola |
| FO | John Antoniades | Sr. | Hofstra |
| LSM | Mason Poli | Sr. | Bryant |
| D | Maxx Meyer | Jr. | Penn |
| D | Matt Miller | Sr. | Notre Dame |
| D | Scott McWilliams | Jr. | Virginia |
| D | Peter Johnson | Sr. | Yale |
| G | Niko Amato | Jr. | Maryland |
HONORABLE MENTION
| A | Joey Sankey | So. | North Carolina |
| A | Kieran McArdle | Jr. | St. John's |
| A | Tucker Hull | Jr. | Navy |
| A | Dan Eipp | Jr. | Harvard |
| A | Keith Dreyer | So. | Air Force |
| A | Dante Fantoni | Sr. | Lehigh |
| A | Nicky Galasso | Jr. | Syracuse |
| A | Miles Thompson | Jr. | Albany |
| A | Jeff Froccaro | Sr. | Princeton |
| A | Alex Love | Jr. | Hobart |
| A | Jimmy Bitter | So. | North Carolina |
| A | Derek Maltz | Jr. | Syracuse |
| A | Robert Church | Sr. | Drexel |
| A | Owen Blye | Sr. | Maryland |
| M | JoJo Marasco | Sr. | Syracuse |
| M | Dave Lawson | Sr. | Duke |
| M | Sam Snow | Sr. | Fairfield |
| M | Lyle Thompson | So. | Albany |
| M | Mike Chanenchuk | Jr. | Maryland |
| M | Cam Flint | Sr. | Denver |
| M | Ryan Tucker | So. | Virginia |
| M | Noah Molnar | Sr. | Lehigh |
| M | Cameron Mann | Sr. | Jacksonville |
| M | Landon Carr | Sr. | Maryland |
| FO | Mike Roe | Jr. | Fairfield |
| FO | Dylan Levings | Jr. | Yale |
| FO | Kevin Massa | So. | Bryant |
| FO | Thomas Croonquist | Jr. | Villanova |
| FO | Doug Tesoriero | Jr. | Cornell |
| LSM | Dillon Ayers | Sr. | St. John's |
| LSM | Pat Kiernan | Jr. | Navy |
| LSM | Roger Ferguson | Sr. | Brown |
| LSM | Jordan Houtby | Sr. | Detroit |
| D | Chris Hipps | Jr. | Duke |
| D | Mike Noone | Sr. | Lehigh |
| D | Brendan Buckley | Sr. | Army |
| D | Mike Bronzino | Sr. | Cornell |
| D | Jason Gonos | Sr. | Harvard |
| D | Reid Acton | Sr. | Loyola |
| D | Casey Carroll | Sr. | Duke |
| D | Mike McCormack | Sr. | Yale |
| D | Rob Castelo | Jr. | Princeton |
| G | Matt Poillon | So. | Lehigh |
| G | Kyle Feeney | Sr. | Bucknell |
| G | Pierce Bassett | Sr. | Johns Hopkins |
| G | Greg Dutton | Jr. | Ohio State |
| G | Jeff Lowman | Sr. | St. John's |