clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Which Villanova Basketball team was better: 2019 vs 2020

They both clinched Big East titles, but who would have won head to head?

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

Villanova Mug Arizin Links

Happy Wednesday Nova Nation! The Big East Tournament kicks off tonight, and we’ll find out who the Villanova Wildcats will be playing tomorrow night when #7 Xavier takes on #10 DePaul. But while we’re waiting to find out who the WIldcats will play, let’s ask what would happen if they took on a different opponent. How about, the 2019 Villanova Wildcats.

Bot this year’s team and last year’s team won Big East titles, and while we have yet to see this younger team in the post season, they’re capable of matching if not exceeding last year’s performances. So let’s go position by position and see who would win.

PG: 2019 Phil Booth vs 2020 Collin Gillespie

Gillespie has made amazing strides this season. Despite being the most accomplished player returning from last season, he has a strong argument for this year’s most improved award. But there’s only one Phil Booth, and 2019 was the year he really showed how he could put a team on his back. You could even argue that we don’t get 2020 Gillespie without the tutelage of 2019 Booth, along with the other Nova point guards that came before him. This would be a really fun matchup to watch, but I think the edge has to go to Booth.

SG: 2019 Collin Gillespie vs 2020 Justin Moore

Speaking of fascinating matchups, this one would be great too. Moore’s defense has really improved throughout the year, and he’s always been able to put the ball through the hoop. On the other end, last year’s Gillespie was a much better facilitator than Moore is while still being a skilled scorer. At the end of the day, this could be a tie. Moore is clearly the more athletic player, but no one outworks Gillespie. Again, I want to see this!

SF: 2019 Saddiq Bey vs 2020 Jermaine Samuels

Seriously, someone build a time machine because I love all of these matchups. Two players that made their way into the starting lineup based on their defense, and then came through with clutch offensive performances. Who wouldn’t want to see either of these guys with the ball in their hand with the game on the line being covered by the other.

PF: 2019 Eric Paschall vs 2020 Saddiq Bey

Two about to be NBA Draft picks going head to head and blow for blow? Yes please! I’ll give the advantage to Paschall because of his experience, but this one would just be an epic battle.

C: 2019 Jermaine Samuels vs 2020 Jeremiah Robinson-Earl

This is an interesting one. Samuels had more trouble bodying up against some of the Big East’s big boys last year, but Robinson-Earl doesn’t have that issue. He’d also do well guarding Jeremiah’s finesse game and have the speed and strength to stay with him on the perimeter and on the open court. By the way, this is all equally true of the Robinson-Earl guarding Samuels. Would these two shut each other down, or would one find a way to score on the other?

Bench: 2019 Joe Cremo plus 2019 AND 2020 Dhamir Cosby-Roundtree, Cole Swider, and Brandon Slater

It’s weird to say, but Nova has basically had the same bench for the past two seasons. Yes, Cosby-Roundtree and Swider both have gotten stints as starters, but at this time last year and now they’re squarely on the bench. Cremo was hot and cold off the bench last season, but he also provided much needed experience off the bench. I’d give the edge to this year’s crew because of experience and injury, but this is probably close to a wash.

As always, I leave it to you Nova Nation. Who would win a matchup between the 2019 and 2020 Villanova Wildcats?


Who would win a game between the 2019 and 2020 Villanova Wildcats?

This poll is closed

  • 37%
    (226 votes)
  • 62%
    (378 votes)
604 votes total Vote Now

Villanova Men’s Basketball

Younger Wildcats team getting ready for Big East Tournament | KYW
Villanova has won three straight Big East tournaments. So farthis season, the current younger team has been impressive. Now, it's on to Madison Square Garden, and coach Jay Wright is hoping his players will handle the pressure. Read more here.

In NCAA basketball postseason, youth will be served ... sometimes on a platter | The Inquirer
Villanova hasn’t always succeeded with its most experienced teams, either. The Wildcats might find a new way this time.

Villanova’s Collin Gillespie follows in his former teammates’ footsteps with probing style of play | The Inquirer
The Wildcats junior has the ball in his hands a lot, and looks for openings and weaknesses in the same way as two of his predecessors, Ryan Arcidiacono and Jalen Brunson.

Big East Tournament

Big East Tournament 2020: Basketball Bracket and Championship Picks | Bleacher Report
The Big East Conference tournament rarely fails to provide great drama and high-quality basketball in pursuit of crowning a champion...

College basketball’s 6 power conference tournament title games we want to see |
Put your rooting interests aside for the moment. These six title games would give us the best combination of quality and drama on conference tournament championship weekend.

2020 Big East Men’s Basketball Tournament: Schedule, Bracket, Recent History, TV/Streaming Info | Blogging the Bracket
Like the Big Ten, the Big East had three teams share its regular-season title, and all three will like their chances to walk away from Madison Square Garden with the title.

After Uncertain Times, The Big East Conference Is Thriving With Basketball-Focused League | Forbes
As the Big East men's basketball tournament begins tonight at Madison Square Garden, the league has proven it can succeed without football. Six or seven of the 10 Big East schools are expected to play in this year's NCAA tournament.

Big 5

Ivy League cancels basketball tournament: Penn's AJ Brodeur says it 'doesn't feel right' | The Inquirer
Brodeur and teammates stunned by decision to cancel the Ivy League tournament

NBA Wildcats

Warriors news: Eric Paschall slams Ivy League tourney cancellation | Clutch Points
Golden State Warriors rookie Eric Paschall had a strong reaction to the Ivy League choosing to cancel its tournament due to the fear of...

Chris Paul, Kyle Lowry both in the running for All-NBA as they continue to make skeptics look foolish |
It could come down to either Paul or Lowry for the final third-team guard spot

Timberwolves' Omari Spellman: Records triple-double |
Timberwolves' Omari Spellman: Records triple-double

Villanova Athletics

Wildcats win home opener 5-1 over NJIT | Villanova University Athletics
Plymouth Meeting, Pa. – Villanova baseball received yet another strong pitching performance to take the home opener 5-1 over NJIT. The Wildcat pitching staff held

Villanova Set to Host Lafayette on Wednesday for 2020 Home Opener | Villanova University Athletics
VILLANOVA, Pa. — After playing 27 games on the road to start the season, Villanova is finally going to get the chance to play on its home field. The Wildcats host

Villanova Looking For First Home Win of the Season | Villanova University Athletics
VILLANOVA, Pa. – Despite a strong start to the season, the Wildcats (2-5) have dropped their last four contests. The team is looking to break that trend when it

19 Wildcats Named to 2019 Zag Field Hockey/NFHCA Division I National Academic Squad | Villanova University Athletics
GILBERT, Ariz. – The National Field Hockey Coaches Association announced on Tuesday that 19 Villanova student-athletes were named to the 2019 Zag Field Hockey/NFHCA


NCAA Basketball 2020: Stock Watch for Bubble Teams at Start of Championship Week | Bleacher Report
Crunch time has arrived for teams on the NCAA tournament bubble, and there's still a ton of movement surrounding the projected cut line...

2020 NCAA Basketball Bracketology: Updated March 10 | Streaking The Lawn
Welcome to the Madness...

Bubble Watch: The mad scramble all comes down to this | The Athletic
Eamonn Brennan updates the NCAA Tournament bubble daily ahead of Selection Sunday.

NCAA tournament bracket projection 2020: Relief for bubble teams |
East Tennessee State and Gonzaga both took care of business, while Saint Mary’s almost assuredly locked up a bid.

College Basketball

It’s Bill Raftery’s world — and we’re all lucky he makes us a part of it | The Athletic
The colorful Raftery will call NCAA Tournament games again and next month will be at the mic for his sixth straight Final Four.

Coronavirus update: Ivy League cancels conference basketball tournaments amid outbreak concerns |
Regular season champions Yale (men's) and Princeton (women's) will earn NCAA Tournament bids

Jay Bilas' college basketball rankings for 2019-20, version 4.0 | ESPN
Want a fair NCAA tournament selection process? Select the at-large teams before the conference tournaments start.